The families’ letter argues that existing responses from the federal government fall far short of what is required. They say Jewish Australians now feel unsafe at schools, universities, workplaces, and public spaces, describing the situation as intolerable in a democratic society.
“We demand answers and solutions,” the letter states. “We need to know why warning signs were ignored, how antisemitic hatred and extremist ideologies were allowed to grow unchecked, and what must be done to ensure this never happens again.”
Alleged Intelligence and Licensing Failures
Questions surrounding intelligence and law enforcement oversight have intensified following revelations that one of the accused attackers, Naveed Akram, had previously been investigated by Australia’s domestic intelligence agency, ASIO, in 2019 over alleged links to extremist networks.
Despite this scrutiny, Akram’s father was later granted a firearms licence, a decision now under intense public and political scrutiny. The accused gunman faces multiple charges, including 15 counts of murder.
Political Divide Over Royal Commission
Prime Minister Albanese has so far resisted calls for a federal royal commission, arguing that such inquiries are time-consuming and could delay urgent reforms. Instead, he announced a limited review led by former ASIO chief Dennis Richardson to examine intelligence coordination.
This approach has drawn sharp criticism from opposition leaders and members within Labor itself. Former Labor MP Mike Kelly stated that only a federal royal commission could compel national agencies to fully cooperate and disclose classified information.
States vs Centre: Jurisdictional Debate
New South Wales Premier Chris Minns has defended the decision to pursue a state-level royal commission, saying it would have sufficient authority to examine the causes of the attack while avoiding interference with ongoing criminal proceedings.
However, critics argue that a state inquiry cannot fully investigate federal intelligence agencies. Opposition leaders, including Nationals chief David Littleproud, have urged the prime minister to reconsider, saying grieving families deserve transparency and accountability.
Antisemitism Declared a National Crisis
The families’ letter stresses that antisemitism in Australia has intensified over the past two and a half years, evolving from verbal abuse and protest slogans into violent acts. They insist the issue transcends state boundaries and demands a national response.
“Royal commissions have been established for banks and aged care,” the letter reads. “We have lost parents, spouses, children, and grandparents. You owe Australians the truth.”
Victims Still Recovering
As of Monday morning, nine victims remain hospitalised in Sydney, with three listed in critical but stable condition. Community vigils continue across Australia, reflecting widespread grief and concern over public safety.
For official information on Australia’s counter-terrorism framework, readers may refer to the Australian Government’s national security portal and related policy updates available through international public records and government briefings.