What Sparked the Controversy
The row began when Rahul Gandhi tried to read passages from the unpublished memoir during a debate in the Lok Sabha. According to Gandhi, the book suggests that India’s political leadership failed to provide clear directions to the military during the escalation with Chinese forces in eastern Ladakh.
The claims relate to the violent clash in the Galwan Valley in June 2020, where 20 Indian soldiers and at least four Chinese troops were killed. It was the first fatal confrontation between the two sides along the disputed Himalayan border since 1975.
Opposition’s Allegations
Gandhi alleged that as Chinese tanks advanced towards Indian positions, General Naravane was told to take decisions as he deemed fit, without explicit political instructions. He argued that this reflected a failure of leadership during a national security crisis.
Quoting what he claimed were passages from the memoir, Gandhi said Naravane felt “abandoned by the entire establishment” at a critical moment. He accused Prime Minister Narendra Modi of “abdicating responsibility” during the Ladakh standoff.
Government Pushback and Rule Violation Claims
The BJP-led government reacted sharply, accusing Gandhi of misleading Parliament and insulting the armed forces. Defence Minister Rajnath Singh and Home Minister Amit Shah objected to Gandhi citing an unpublished book, calling it a violation of parliamentary rules.
Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju said that while Gandhi was allowed to speak, he could not force unverified or unpublished material into the House record. He maintained that quoting from an unreleased manuscript was not permissible.
Repeated Disruptions and Suspensions
The heated exchanges led to repeated adjournments of the Lok Sabha over multiple days. When Gandhi attempted to raise the issue again, BJP members interrupted him, resulting in fresh protests from the Opposition.
On Tuesday, eight Congress MPs were suspended for disorderly conduct, further escalating tensions. Proceedings in both Houses were repeatedly stalled as slogan shouting drowned out debates.
Memoir Under Government Review
General Naravane, who served as Army Chief from 2019 to 2022, has not publicly commented on the controversy. His memoir reportedly covers his personal life and professional career, including the 2020 China standoff.
The book’s publication has been delayed amid reports that it contains sensitive operational details. Under existing rules, retired military and intelligence officials must seek clearance before publishing material that could affect India’s sovereignty, integrity, or national security.
Rules on Military Publications
Retired officers are required to submit manuscripts to their parent organisations for review if they include operational or classified information. Approval may be granted, modifications suggested, or publication denied if the content is deemed sensitive.
Similar memoirs by former senior officers have been published in the past, but only after clearance. The Ministry of Defence has not issued any official statement on the status of Naravane’s book.
China Standoff Still Politically Sensitive
The 2020 Ladakh crisis remains a deeply sensitive political issue. Rahul Gandhi has repeatedly accused the government of conceding territory to China, allegations the Centre has consistently denied, stating that no Indian land was lost.
Tensions along the Line of Actual Control eased in 2024 following prolonged military and diplomatic negotiations, with both sides agreeing to disengagement in friction points.
Broader Political Impact
The memoir row has added to the already strained atmosphere of the ongoing Budget Session, raising questions about parliamentary conduct, freedom of expression, and the handling of national security debates.
